Name of Restaurant: Pagliai’s Pizza & Pasta
Location of Restaurant: 1129 Broadway St, Cape Girardeau, MO
This place has been around since the mid-’60′s. One can imagine why because as soon as you step in, you are enveloped by the amazing smell and the set up they’ve got going on. It makes you feel like you aren’t in some college town.
I can’t ever think of a better pizza that I’ve ever had. They hand make the dough right there in the restaurant. Since it is busy enough, it is always fresh. They also happen to make the sauce, which is spicy enough to tantilize any tastebud, though not overwhelming for those who can’t handle heat. Needless to say, it was perfect. Most pizza joints use shredded cheese on their pizza’s-not here. They slice the cheese off a block, which makes it nice and stringy cheesey. They also have their own slicers when they slice meats and veggies. Perfect.
If you are ever in Cape and have a hankering for a pizza, go to Pagliai’s. You’ll not find a better pizza.
Directions-coming off of Interstate 55 going S.
-Take a left at the light onto William St (of K, as is also known as)
-Take a left at the Kingshighway light.
-Make a right on Broadway
The restaurant is located right across from the entrance to get into the University.
Final rating: 5 stars
« Old Brick House, Ste. Genevieve, MO TK’s Pizzaria, De Soto, MO »

Thanks, Morgan :)
Lovely review :)
Can’t wait to try this. Great review.
Has become a favorite of ours everytime we visit my daughter at school at CG. Never miss going there. Don’t know what we’ll do when she graduates.
That was the nasties pizza I have ever eatin.
I almost puked
barf
Absolutely excellent!!!! I recommend the Italian Sausage and Mushroom on Whole Wheat crust.
Best Pizza I have ever eaten.
PIZZA GREAT! GOOD SERVICE! REALLY ENJOYED THE FOOD AND ATMOSPHERE. THEY DO A GREAT BUSINESS.
Fabulous food and terrific customer service. This is a place that you can take your family and not be concerned about the food that is presented ( it is delicious) or the atmosphere (very family oriented). Visit here every trip I make to Cape.
Best Pizza ever! Great selection and service!
This restaurant told me they took checks over the phone when I placed my order and then, once they delivered the pizza, they refused my check. The owner told me it was because of the neighborhood I live in. They think your money is no good if you live in a poorer part of town.
I got a vegetable pizza carryout.By the time I made it the 3 blocks home the grease had soaked all the way through the cardboard box and saturated the car seat. You would not expect that from a veg pie. It was so discusting I tossed it.
this is the worst pizza iv had.. Its extremely greasy. I felt like having a heartattack just looking at it.The man is a racist pig too.
I certainly wouldn’t call this the worst pizza I’ve ever had, but it isn’t even close to the best either. The best description that comes to mind is average. Customer service was good, and it’s a very clean establishment…but the pizza isn’t anything special.